Pairing Literature with Primary Sources
Feature
We all love a good story. You can make history come alive through picture books. Pair them with primary sources from online digital collections and history can become more than a series of facts. Just as in a good story, students identify with struggles and accomplishments of main characters, drawing parallels to their own lives and times.
At Gates Elementary in Chesterfield County, Virginia, we transformed learning with a "story" program for fourth and fifth grade students. Inspired by Book Backdrops developed by Gail Petri at the Library of Congress (LOC), we collected picture books that correlated to our state social studies standards. Some featured historical figures like George Washington, others featured artists, scientists, and everyday people set in extraordinary circumstances. For each book, we located photographs, paintings, videos, and testimonials that transformed the stories into real experiences to relive and retell. Shared below are a few highlights of this successful unit that can be easily replicated.
Students met Revolutionary War heroes George Washington and the Marquis de Lafayette through Revolutionary Friends: General George Washington and the Marquis de Lafayette by Selene Castrovilla.
The book conveys the bond that developed between these two historical figures. Pair this story with paintings and prints in the digital archives at LOC. Begin by exploring "A Revolutionary Partnership" at America's Story from America's Library (http://www.americaslibrary.gov/jb/revolut/jb_revolut_francoam_1.html). Students can also examine John Dunsmore's painting Washington and Lafayette at Valley Forge, the Currier and Ives print The First Meeting of Washington and Lafayette, and the Philip Haas lithograph Valley Forge, 1777. Gen. Washington and Lafayette Visiting the Suffering Part of the Army.
We divided students into groups and had them examine the prints and describe how the artists depicted the conditions at Valley Forge. Students imagined the qualities of leadership Washington and Lafayette needed to exhibit under such circumstances.
Abraham Lincoln takes on a more human persona in Karen B. Winnick's Mr. Lincoln's Whiskers. It tells the true story of Grace Bedell who wrote a letter to Lincoln advising him to grow a beard during the presidential campaign of 1860. This book is used as the example in the Book Backdrops activity in LOC's Teaching with Primary Sources: Professional Development (http://www.loc.gov/teachers/professionaldevelopment/tpsdirect/pdf/Book-Backdrops.pdf). The PDF lists numerous primary sources including campaign buttons, photographs of Lincoln with and without a beard, letters, and political charts. Suggested teaching strategies listed under "Creating Book Backdrops Using the Inquiry Method" include
- Use the photographs as writing prompts for a paragraph, letter, or short story
- Write dialogue by creating speech bubbles on the photographs
- Research an artifact or photograph and write a news article
Following this model, students can take a historical trip back to other presidential elections by researching digital collections at LOC and then create books, posters, or thought bubbles superimposed on candidates' photographs.
Immigration is the oldest continuous story in our country's history. The plight, perseverance, and ingenuity of early immigrants are portrayed in The Matchbox Diary by Paul Fleischman. We introduced the concept of immigration with the 1902 photograph "Emigrants Coming to the 'Land of Promise'." In small groups, our students used LOC's Primary Source Analysis Tool (http://www.loc.gov/teachers/primary-source-analysis-tool/) to analyze, reflect on, and question what they observed. Each student contributed opinions and information about the photograph. They listened to the suggestions made by others, collected ideas, and shared with the whole class. Applying their current knowledge of the world, some students identified the women as Muslim because their heads were covered. Additional research solved the riddle this picture presents for students today. For more primary sources on immigration see the Themed Resources page at LOC (http://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/themes/).
Picture a library filled with bright balls of yarn with 5th grade boys and girls knitting with pencils, wooden skewers, or perhaps a few knitting needles. After we read Deborah Hopkinson's Knit Your Bit: A World War I Story and viewed Red Cross posters from World War I, our students were motivated to try their hands at knitting. They recognized the pain soldiers felt in wet trenches without warm socks to combat trench foot. Photographs showing students knitting inspired our students to keep practicing weeks after the story had been shared.
The tragic story of the Holocaust is told in Karen Hesse's The Cats in Krasinski Square, the story of one little girl's brave deed tohelp the Resistance sneak food into the Warsaw Ghetto. Pair this story with Tomek Bogacki's Champion of Children: The Story of Janusz Korczak, about a doctor who ran a Jewish orphanage and video footage of real heroes of the Holocaust such as Irena Sendler, a Polish social worker who smuggled many orphans out of the Ghetto (http://www.irenasendler.org/).
These books are only a few of the ones that can be paired with primary sources, and history is not the only subject that benefits from this practice. For science, check out Jennifer Bern's biography of Albert Einstein, On a Beam of Light. For math, try Joseph D'Agnese's Blockhead: The Life of Fibonacci. Use your online search skills to locate photographs, news articles, and video clips to pair with these books and others. Through expert pairing of stories real and imagined, we can construct experiences that stimulate new learning. We found that our students responded more favorably to all subjects when they had visuals or hands-on experiences. Using picture books in the upper elementary grade levels has become a part of the library lesson plan at Gates. For additional resources and titles, visit the Google Site created for our 2016 VAASL presentation on "Pairing Literature with Primary Sources" at https://sites.google.com/a/ccpsnet.net/pairing-literature-with-primary-sources/.
Berns, Jennifer. On a Beam of Light: A Story of Albert Einstein. Illus. by Vladimir Radunsky. Chronicle Books, 2016.
Bogacki, Tomek. The Champion of the Children: The Story of Janusz Korczak. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009.
Castrovilla, Selene. Revolutionary Friends: General George Washington and the Marquis de Lafayette. Illus. by Drazen Kozjan. Calkins Creek, 2013.
D'Agnese, Joseph. Blockhead: The Life of Fibonacci. Illus. by John O'Brien. Henry Holt, 2010.
Fleischman, Paul. The Matchbox Diary. Illus. by Bagram Ibatoulline. Candlewick, 2013.
Hesse, Karen, and Wendy Watson. The Cats in Krasinski Square
Hopkinson, Deborah, and Steven Guarnaccia. Knit Your Bit: A World War I Story. G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2013.
Winnick, Karen B. Mr. Lincoln's Whiskers. Boyds Mills, 1996.
About the Authors
Katharine Lehman is a National Board Certified Librarian recently retired from Chesterfield County, VA., and teaches library science classes as an adjunct at Old Dominion University. She edited and contributed to Interacting with History: Teaching with Primary Sources. ALA Editions, 2014.
Sheila Dunn is the librarian at Gates Elementary School in Chesterfield County, VA, a school with an average of 750 students. She has been in this position for three years and was voted Teacher of the Year 2015-2016 by her staff.
MLA Citation
Lehman, Katharine, and Sheila Dunn. "Pairing Literature with Primary Sources." School Library Connection, November 2016, schoollibraryconnection.com/Content/Article/2046625.
https://schoollibraryconnection.com/Content/Article/2046625?topicCenterId=0
Entry ID: 2046625